Standing Rock Update: Non-violence vs 7-State Army

war-zone-mapOn October 27, a combination of military-equipped police forces from seven states and multiple counties, at the request of North Dakota Governor Jack Dalrymple, violently forced their way thru non-violent protesters and removed the Treaty Camp (also known as the Frontline Camp, see map).  Immediately behind them, providing a stunning display of industrial-military cooperation, construction crews were working.

In the five days since, the joint military/construction operation has completed clearing the pipeline corridor across Highway 1806 all the way to the drill pad, where they will begin tunneling under Lake Oahe (the Missouri River).  (This blog post and this article detail how the US Army Corp economically devastated the Standing Rock and Cheyenne River Indian Reservations in 1960 when they created Lake Oahe.)


Square drill pad with the Missouri River/Lake Oahe in the background.  Pipeline corridor in foreground; green pipe at left waiting to go under the river.  From drone footage obtained despite an FAA no-fly zone over the area.

And now, here we wait.  The Obama Administration has revoked the US Army Corp permit to go under the river, pending further evaluation– probably “meaningful consultation” with the affected tribes and an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) (basically, a long permit review process that includes public comment).  These steps will take months and almost certainly turn the final decision over to the next administration.  When they revoked the permit on September 9, the Obama Administration had asked Energy Transfer Partners (owners of Dakota Access Pipeline) to voluntarily halt construction for 20 miles on either side of the river, presumably for potential re-routing of the pipeline.  (The request was voluntary because the feds have no authority except on Army Corp property at the river.)  The company completely ignored this request, instead working at breakneck speed, with their violent military escort, to dig right up to the edge of Army Corp lands at the river.  In comments on November 1, President Obama was explicitly clear that re-routing is an option.

The use of violent state militias to clear lands of non-violent Native Americans, while the federal government stands by, recalls dozens of historical events.  Most prominently, the massacre at Sand Creek was carried out by Colonel John Chivington and a militia from the


Sand Creek site near Chivington, Colorado

State of Colorado.  Unable to find the actual Indians they were looking for (who had killed several white settler families), they targeted Black Kettle’s peaceful camp of elders, women, and children, camped under an American flag and a white flag of truce.  The result was an estimated 100-200 dead.  Chivington and his Colorado militia celebrated with a parade through downtown Denver, holding Native scalps and other body parts aloft for all to see.  Likewise, the genocide in California was largely a state enterprise, with volunteer militias attacking Native villages, enslaving the children, and getting reimbursed by the state for their expenses.

In this case, the state militias at Standing Rock appear to be heavily subsidized by surplus US military equipment, which has been liberally bestowed upon law enforcement agencies across the nation in recent years (see video trailer above).  While federal laws regarding tribal consultation and environmental review have proved no obstacle for the pipeline, it appears that public pressure and concern for the Standing Rock Sioux has at least spared them live ammunition.

direct-actionThe commitment to non-violence of the protesters at Sacred Stone Camp, the headquarters for the movement, can be seen both in the video footage above and in this sign posted at the entrance to the camp.  For a more complete account of life at the camp, see this thoughtful blog post.

My new post explains why the Dakota Access Pipeline no longer makes economic sense:

The Dakota Access Pipeline is unnecessary

Here are my previous posts on Standing Rock and the Dakota Access Pipeline, which focus more on the history and current status of the conflict on the ground:

This entry was posted in news, Standing Rock and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Standing Rock Update: Non-violence vs 7-State Army

  1. Excellent interview with Standing Rock Tribal Chairman David Archambault. He discusses his meeting with the Army Corp, camp safety in the face of winter, the presence of Morton County and state law enforcement troops on Army Corp land, and other issues. At -9:00 he explains that, in 2007, the tribe passed a resolution that no pipelines be permitted on their ancestral lands.

  2. Yesterday Morton County and state law enforcement maced demonstrators standing in the Cannonball River and shot them with rubber bullets. They did this from Army Corp land just north of the river. Here the tribe is challenging the Army Corp for allowing that, where the tribe has a legal right to be, and for delegating their federal relationship with the tribe to state and county militias:

  3. Pingback: A Showdown Looms at Standing Rock – #NoDAPL

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s